)
Save up to $100 on select Oklahoma Joe Products
This item leaves our warehouse within
1-3 Business Days
Key Features
- FUEL: Charcoal fuel with height-adjustable tray allows you to grill with high heat or cook low and slow
- SIZE: 540-square-inches of primary cooking space
- MATERIAL: Heavy-gauge steel construction ensures durability you can trust
- CONTROLS: Professional temperature gauge with glow-in-the-dark accents and large air dampers allow for accurate airflow control
Legal disclaimers and warnings
Product packaging, owners’ manuals, installation instructions, and/or operating instructions may include more information than what is shown on our website. The content on our site is intended to be used for reference purposes only. Please fully read all included manuals and documentation before installing or using this product. WARNING for California residents: this product may contain chemical(s) known to the state of California to cause birth defects, cancer, or other reproductive harm.
)
Ask an Expert
Expert Help, Zero Hassle
Stop Searching, Start Living
Advice We Stand Behind
Learning Center
Warranty
Refer to manufacturer's manual for full warranty details.
Related Departments
Customer Reviews
70 reviews
Central NY
Jun 16, 2025
I love this grill! Very easy to regulate the heat, especially with the adjustable height on the coal tray. I can have two different fires going on either side and still have an indirect section in the middle. The ash pan might be easier to work with if it were in two sections. The door on the front seems too small to be able to safely add lit coals. Still, I like this way better than my old Webber!
Huntsville, Alabama
Jun 4, 2025
This is my 2nd Grill from Oklahoma Joe, I love them but my "JUDGE" Charcoal Grill lacks the quality as my drum smoker. The spot welds on the bottom pan has busted loose and I don't know of a fix for this other than trying to take it to a welder or hopefully get a replacement. I have used these products for almost 8 years now and hope the quality is not going to start dropping.. hopefully I just got a bad part....
Cypress, Tx
May 10, 2025
I ordered this online. Arrived cple days ago and I assembled it. Sat 5/10/25. Followed instructions , pretty easy. As I finished , I noticed the lid didn't close properly. I grabbed my measuring tape and I measured the box and noticed it wasn't squared. I attached pictures.
1 user found this review helpful
Florissant
Apr 14, 2025
Needed a better direct heat grill....my offset Highland smokes only. So i grabbed rhe Judge..
Topsham VT
Apr 9, 2025
I have had this grill since 2020, I use it during the warmer months 5 days a week. I can not speak highly enough. I also have been able to smoke some great meats by offsetting the heat from the meat because of the large cooking area. The only issue is after five years I need a new ash tray, which is available to order....... pretty impressive.
Chattanooga TN
Feb 7, 2025
4 years into cooking on this grill and it still is a top performer. Quality construction make it much more durable than other grills at the same price point. Adjustable charcoal tray is great for different cooking styles. I can easily crank it to 800+ deg. or I can lock it down with one vent open and the chimney cracked and it will hold low steady temps for a long time. Can't recommend it enough
Raleigh, NC
Nov 29, 2024
I have had my Judge grill for a couple of years now and I love it. I assembled it myself. It is solid and has no smoke leaks. I love being able to add coals or wood when cooking several chickens and pouring on sauce. Temperature regulation is fairly easy and it is great for cooking and searing steaks at high temps.
2 users found this review helpful
Albuquerque, NM
Nov 26, 2024
Disappointed, this charcoal grill is not made from the same steel that they use on the offset smokers. Was really hoping for a heavy duty charcoal grill that would last 20+ years. I am guessing I'll get maybe 10 years out of this (if the welds hold) as much as I use my grills. Also, in agreement with the majority of reviews that the welding on this leaves much to be desired. How hard is it to weld an entire area versus these poor tack welds on everything just weld the entire piece all the way around. Sad to see corporate takeover diminish the quality of a home grown quality American product. Char Broiler you all should be ashamed what you have done to t his brand....I'll pay the extra $100-$200 dollars, give us a quality product!!!!!
1 user found this review unhelpful
Planada, California
Oct 15, 2024
Best Charcoal grill I have ever purchased. Thank you
Chicago, IL
Jul 6, 2024
Great grilling machine & smoker in one. Love my OKJ Judge charcoal grill
Questions & Answers
Be the first to write a question!
Compare Similar Items
Current Item | ||||
Class | Entry-Level | Practical | Practical | Luxury |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Size | Large (34 - 42") | Large (34 - 42") | Large (34 - 42") | Large (34 - 42") |
Primary Color | Black | Black | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
Made In USA | No | Made In The USA With Globally Sourced Parts | No | No |
Exterior Material | Painted Steel | Porcelain Coated Steel | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
Fuel Type | Charcoal | Charcoal | Charcoal | Charcoal |
Configuration | Freestanding | Freestanding | Freestanding | Freestanding |
WiFi/Bluetooth Enabled | None | None | None | None |
Cooking Grid Dimensions | 18 X 30" | 37 1/2 Inch Diameter | 33 3/4 X 18" | 33 1/2 X 16 1/2" |
Side Burner | None | None | None | None |
Grill Lights | None | None | None | -- |
Side Shelves | Yes | No | Yes | Yes |
Side Shelf Material | Steel | -- | Stainless Steel | Stainless Steel |
Cart Assembly | Some Assembly Required | Some Assembly Required | Some Assembly Required | Some Assembly Required |
Total Cooking Capacity | 540 Sq. Inches | 1104 Sq. Inches | 605 Sq. Inches | 862 Sq. Inches |
On Wheels | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
Cooking Grate Material | Cast Iron | Stainless Steel | Cast Iron | Stainless Steel |
Burger Count | 18 | 68 | -- | -- |
Spring Assisted Hood | No | No | No | -- |
Thermometer | Analog | None | Analog | None |
Commercial-Grade Multi-User | No | No | No | No |
Marine Grade | No | No | No | No |
Width | 59.9" | 37.7" | 67.5" | 93" |
Height | 47.5" | 42" | 49.5" | 64.5" |
Depth | 26.5" | 44.7" | 24.75" | 23.8" |
Weight | 215 lbs | 148 lbs | 235 lbs | 450 lbs |
)
)
)
)
Proposition 65
For more information, go to www.p65warnings.ca.gov
Shipping & Returns
Free Shipping on orders over $49
Ship your entire order to your home for free, especially the big stuff!
*Continental US only
When will my item arrive?
Once shipped, items usually arrive within 3-5 business days. While UPS and FedEx are our carriers for smaller items, be aware that larger items and orders are shipped via freight. The freight process is a bit more complicated than what we've all come to expect for small parcels, so it's important that you're prepared and understand what's required of you well before delivery day.
- Most freight products ship on a pallet
- Some carriers will call to schedule a delivery window, while others will deliver the shipment to a reasonably accessible location closest to your residence (their goal is to deliver as near a garage door as they can).
- We'll specify which process you can expect in your shipping confirmation email.
For carriers that schedule delivery appointments:
Carriers that schedule delivery appointments require you to be home for delivery and provide your signature. The delivery is made with a semi-truck with lift gate services, and the shipment is dropped off at the curb. If you authorize the shipping company to leave the delivery without a signature, BBQGuys can't be held responsible for damages that occur during delivery. As complicated as this process may seem, we've only scratched the surface here — please review our detailed guide to freight delivery so there are no surprises when a freight shipment heads your way.
For carriers that deliver without an appointment:
Carriers that deliver without an appointment don't require you to be home or set up a delivery window, and you aren't required to sign for the pallet(s). Instead of scheduling an appointment, arranging your schedule to be home for the delivery, and signing to confirm receipt, you can sit back and let your items come to you. If you're home at the time of the drop-off, you can request the driver place your delivery in the garage; if you're out of the house, the driver will leave it near the garage or doorstep.
This item leaves our warehouse within 1-3 Business Days
$49 Flat-Rate Shipping
Anything under $49 ships at one low price. If your order increases, your shipping stays the same!
30-Day Returns
Return all new, unused, and unassembled items in their original packaging, and we'll give you a full refund minus the cost of the original AND return shipping.
No Restocking Fee
Most companies charge a restocking fee. We just don't do business that way.
